Friday, April 16, 2021
NEWS ZHIT
  • Home
  • World
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Economics
  • Sports
  • Science & Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Travel
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Economics
  • Sports
  • Science & Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Travel
No Result
View All Result
News Zhit
No Result
View All Result
Home Economics

Biden’s plan to forgive student debt could have limited economic benefits, and carry risks

newsz by newsz
December 6, 2020
in Economics
0
Biden’s plan to forgive student debt could have limited economic benefits, and carry risks
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


U.S. President-elect Joe Biden gestures to reporters as he arrives to announce nominees and appointees to serve on his economic policy team at his transition headquarters in Wilmington, Delaware, U.S., December 1, 2020.

Leah Millis | Reuters

If President-elect Joe Biden follows through on his campaign promise to forgive student loans to many borrowers, he’ll be checking off an important box for his political constituency.

As a boost to the struggling U.S. economy, however, the move may not have much impact and will draw substantial opposition early in his presidency.

What to do about the burgeoning $1.6 trillion in education debt has been a nagging question for government officials. Fully half of the debt has piled up over the past decade, when effective nationalization of the process opened a floodgate of tuition increases and college loans that left many graduates struggling to pay bills, buy homes and raise families.

The most likely path Biden will follow is a $10,000 forgiveness plan at a time when the average burden per graduate is just shy of $30,000.

That would provide an aggregate savings of more than $400 billion, according to many estimates.

But in doing so, it would raise a series of thorny questions that the new administration may have a hard time answering. Among them are issues over wealth inequality, given that higher-income borrowers owe a larger share, moral hazard of wiping out loans to a select group, and whether forgiveness is even the most effective way to address the issue.

“There is growing evidence that student loan debt does have macroeconomic consequences,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics. “Outside of mortgage debt, it’s the largest amount of household debt outstanding, and it’s still growing rapidly.”

Indeed, education loans outstanding totaled just $480 billion at the beginning of 2006. However, two pieces of legislative action that effectively guaranteed access to college, and the funds needed to pay the way, caused that figure to jump 67% over the next four years to $800 billion, and it’s more than doubled that total in the decade since.

Studies have linked the burden to lower household formation, higher delinquency rates and lower confidence about the future for borrowers.

But whether just wiping the slate clean would really help is an open question.

For his part, even while Zandi insists the idea would benefit the middle class, he sees significant weakness.

“How I would provide relief to hard-pressed student loan borrowers, I think I’d focus more on income-based repayment plans,” he said. “If you’re really trying to address our long-term education needs, which I think is critical to long-term economic growth, we need to be thinking more expansively about providing higher levels of education at a much lower cost.”

Providing outright debt relief, he added, raises the question of, “Do we really want to subsidize tuitions? That’s what you’re doing. You’re giving money to students to give to universities that raised the tuition … and it doesn’t really help anybody.”

Tying debt to income

The larger efficacy question of loan forgiveness was the study of a working paper released last month by the prestigious University of Chicago Booth School of Business.

Researchers Sylvain Catherine, of the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business, and Constantine Yannelis, from the Booth school, compared the benefits of forgiveness against those of income-based payment plans that Zandi mentioned. They found the latter provided better benefit, particularly for lower-income borrowers.

Those with higher debt loans, the study found, tend to be students in post-graduate programs who also are making more money. Thus, they would benefit more from forgiveness and widen a growing disparity among income classes in the U.S.

“We find that universal and capped forgiveness policies are highly regressive, with the vast majority of benefits accruing to high-income individuals,” the authors said. “On the other hand, enrolling more borrowers in [Income-Driven Repayment] plans linking repayment to earnings leads to forgiveness for borrowers in the middle of the income-distribution.”

Current IDR plans, as they are known, would have payments pegged at 10%-15% of discretionary income for borrowers with incomes 150% above the poverty line. Any remaining balances would be forgiven after 20-25 years. The provisions mean that low-income debt holders still might end up paying nothing or very little over the lives of their loans.

“Forgiveness would benefit the top decile as much as the bottom three deciles combined,” Catherine and Yannelis wrote. “Blacks and Hispanics would also benefit substantially less than balances suggest. Enrolling households who would benefit from income-driven repayment is the least expensive and most progressive policy we consider.”

Political questions

Selling those types of economics, though, could be tough at a time when debt holders and progressive politicians on Biden’s side of the aisle are demanding immediate relief.

The president-elect made such populist themes as easing the student loan burden a centerpiece of his campaign and he will be pushed to come through, with some members of his party advocating forgiveness as high as $50,000.

Following through, “will be transformational and provide a boost to Biden’s approval among the borrowers who will benefit, further cementing educated millennials and other post-generation X age cohorts into the Democratic coalition,” Beacon Research said in a recent policy note on the issue.

Beacon said it expects the issue to be part of Biden’s first-100-days agenda.

But opposition is likely to be substantial, providing an early faceoff for the new president and Republican lawmakers who could still control the Senate.

The Committee for a Responsible Budget, fearing more kindling on the nation’s $27.4 trillion debt, said the $115 billion to $260 billion economic benefit would yield “a much smaller return than other options available to policymakers.”

The organization said government spending would be more beneficial in the form of direct payments like extended unemployment benefits, which are part of stimulus packages being bandied about in Congress.

There also will be general political backlash on moral hazard grounds from those who see folly in rewarding students for racking up huge debts they couldn’t afford to colleges who took advantage of government largesse to jack up costs.

Government has “allowed universities to go on this crazy trajectory of increasing their costs without any additional benefit to students,” said Carol Roth, head of Intercap Merchant Partners.

“Colleges bear a lot of the responsibility, and they have basically been taking the dollars facilitated by government in a predatory way,” she added.

While Roth acknowledges the larger economic issues, she said it’s wrong that taxpayers have to pick up the tab for some borrowers and not others.

“We have to move away from governments picking winners and losers,” she said. “The government shouldn’t be doing that, and it’s not fair to have people who decided not to go to college, whether it’s directly or indirectly, bearing the burden for the situation they had no role in causing.”



Source link

Tags: benefitsBidenscarrydebteconomicforgivelimitedplanrisksstudent
newsz

newsz

Related Posts

Jacob Everett of the Indiana Economic Development Association Legislative Committee – WISH-TV | Indianapolis News | Indiana Weather
Economics

Jacob Everett of the Indiana Economic Development Association Legislative Committee – WISH-TV | Indianapolis News | Indiana Weather

March 3, 2021
AP Top Entertainment News at 6:33 a.m. EST
Economics

EMERGING MARKETS-Real, Mexican peso lead Latam FX losses on economic uncertainty – Yahoo Finance

March 3, 2021
Mask mandate is about life, not economics, Edwards mayor says
Economics

Mask mandate is about life, not economics, Edwards mayor says

March 3, 2021
Next Post
The 10 best video games of 2020, according to critics

The 10 best video games of 2020, according to critics

Latest news from around the world

Latest news from around the world

St. Lawrence Cruise Lines Awarded Safe Travel Stamp – Cruise Industry News

St. Lawrence Cruise Lines Awarded Safe Travel Stamp - Cruise Industry News

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Week 16 NFL odds, picks, schedule, how to watch, streaming: Expert picks against the spread, best bets, more

Week 16 NFL odds, picks, schedule, how to watch, streaming: Expert picks against the spread, best bets, more

4 months ago
How fashion choices at the inauguration made a statement

How fashion choices at the inauguration made a statement

3 months ago
Viola Davis broke down over Chadwick Boseman’s death | Entertainment News

Viola Davis broke down over Chadwick Boseman’s death | Entertainment News

4 months ago
Rep.-elect Luke Letlow dies from Covid complications days before being sworn in

Rep.-elect Luke Letlow dies from Covid complications days before being sworn in

4 months ago

Categories

  • Business
  • Economics
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Finance
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Science & Technology
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • World

Topics

announces BBC Biden business businesses City Coronavirus County COVID COVID19 economic Entertainment Fashion finance financial Global health high Jobs latest LIVE Local Million National News pandemic Political Politics recovery Report school Science small Sports state Stories technology Top Travel Trump UPDATES vaccine Week world Year
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Daily News

John Cox Named Chief Growth Officer at SprintRay

Changes To March-In Rights Under Bayh-Dole And More? | Goodwin

New Science Indicates Mars’ Water Didn’t Escape to Space – It’s Trapped in the Red Planet’s Crust

CO2 electrotransformation into value-added chemicals in ionic liquid-based electrolytes

A Harvard Astronomer Said It’s Alien Technology – Now Scientists Think They Found the True Origin of Strange Interstellar Object

Trending

Glass crystallization making red phosphor for high-power warm white lighting
Science & Technology

Glass crystallization making red phosphor for high-power warm white lighting

by newsz
March 18, 2021
0

IMAGE: (a), MgO-Al2O3-SiO2 ternary glass section diagram, exhibiting the glass chemical composition situates at cordierite (chemical components...

Cummings says Covid response held back by EU and ‘smoking ruin’ department

Cummings says Covid response held back by EU and ‘smoking ruin’ department

March 18, 2021
Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Daily News

Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Press Telegram

March 18, 2021
Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Daily News

Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Daily News

March 18, 2021
John Cox Named Chief Growth Officer at SprintRay

John Cox Named Chief Growth Officer at SprintRay

March 18, 2021

Recent News

Glass crystallization making red phosphor for high-power warm white lighting

Glass crystallization making red phosphor for high-power warm white lighting

March 18, 2021
Cummings says Covid response held back by EU and ‘smoking ruin’ department

Cummings says Covid response held back by EU and ‘smoking ruin’ department

March 18, 2021
Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Daily News

Resolution to close Playa del Rey gas facility advanced by LA City Council committee – Press Telegram

March 18, 2021

Category

  • Business
  • Economics
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Finance
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Science & Technology
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • World

Follow Us

Contact Us

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Amazon Disclosure

© 2020 News Zhit

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Finance
  • Economics
  • Sports
  • Science & Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Travel

© 2020 News Zhit